Saving Buddhist Heritage During Soviet Antireligious Policy: The Story of Two Tanks from the Altsinkhuta Tract

Annotation

This study is of significant scientific relevance due to the insufficient study of the fate of Buddhist heritage in the USSR in the context of the antireligious policies of the 1920s and 1930s. In Soviet and Russian historiography, repressions against Buddhist culture remain understudied. An analysis of the antireligious propaganda of the 1920s and 1930s shows that it was pervasive and included legislative measures. This study introduces a specific microhistorical story about the rescue of two Buddhist thangkas, demonstrating strategies for preserving religious artifacts under conditions of ideological pressure. The main goal of the study is to reconstruct the historical path of two Buddhist thangkas from the Altsinkhuta tract as a cross-cutting narrative reflecting the stages of state policy towards religious heritage. The study traces the full life cycle of religious artifacts – from ritual use through confiscation and museum storage to their return to the context of a resurgent regional culture. Additional objectives include identifying the role of the individual in preserving cultural heritage (using the example of scholar L. Z. Zakharov) and analyzing the continuity of the state's approach to religious heritage – from outright destruction to partial restitution. The study is based on a comprehensive analysis of diverse sources: materials from the State Archives of the Russian Federation, the State Archives of the Saratov Region, and museum documents from the Stavropol State Historical, Cultural, Natural, and Landscape Museum-Reserve named after G. N. Prozritelev and G. K. Prave; visual sources – Buddhist thangkas themselves with their iconographic features; and Soviet-era legislative acts regulating religious policy. The methodological framework incorporates the core principle of historicism, as well as historical-systemic and chronological methods, allowing for a historical perspective and systemic connections to be considered in the research object. A microhistorical approach is crucial, allowing for the uncovering of large-scale historical processes through individual cases. The study led to the following conclusions: the antireligious campaign in Kalmykia was all-encompassing, leading to the complete destruction of religious buildings, as evidenced by the fate of the khurul complex in Altsinkhuta. Despite systematic antireligious propaganda, the state failed to completely eradicate the religious component. In the post-war period, the state's approach shifted from a tactic of destruction to the managed existence of religious institutions and the partial restitution of cultural heritage. The micro-history of two thangkas from Altsinkhuta illustrates the general pattern of preserving religious identity at the local level, which subsequently allowed for its revival.

Keywords

• Antireligious policy of the Soviet state,
• antireligious campaign
• Buddhist cultural heritage
• Kalmykia
• Buddhist thangkas
• Altsinkhut khurul complex
• cultural heritage preservation
• religious artifacts
• museumification of religious objects
• restitution of religious heritage
• secret Buddhist practices
* click on a keyword to go to the search

References

1. Abaeva, L. L. Vosstanovleniye buddiyskikh monastyrey etnicheskoy Buryatii v poslevoennyy period [Restoration of Buddhist Monasteries in Ethnic Buryatia in the postwar period]. Vestnik Buryatskogo nauchnogo tsentra SO RAN [Bulletin of the Buryat Scientific Center, Siberian Branch of the Russian Academy of Sciences]. 2015, no. 3 (19), pp. 52–57.

2. Avlyaev, G. O. Kalmyk Khurals in the 19th Century [Kalmyk khuruls in the 19th century]. Lamaizm v Kalmykii [Lamaism in Kalmykia]. Elista: Kalmyk Scientific Research Institute of Language, Literature and History; 1977, pp. 56–69.

3. Andreev, A. I. Tibet v politike carskoj, sovetskoj i postsovetskoj Rossii [Tibet in the Politics of Tsarist, Soviet, and Post-Soviet Russia]. Saint Petersburg: Saint Petersburg State University; Nartang; 2006, 465 p.

4. Badmaeva, E. N. Religioznaya politika sovetskogo gosudarstva v period NEPa: na primere Kalmytskoy avtonomnoy oblasti [Religious policy of the Soviet state during the NEP period: the example of the Kalmyk Autonomous Oblast]. Nauchnye vedomosti Belgorodskogo gosudarstvennogo universiteta [Scientific bulletin of Belgorod State University]. 2009, no. 1 (56), vol. 9. pp. 107–113.

5. Badmaeva, E. N. Gosudarstvennaya politika i religioznaya situatsiya v Nizhnem Povolzhe v 1920−1930-e gg. [State policy and religious situation in the Lower Volga region in the 1920–1930s]. Buddizm v Rossii i na Zapade: istoricheskiy opyt i sovremennye realii [Buddhism in Russia and in the West: historical experience and modern realities]. Elista: Dzhangar; 2012, pp. 25–30.

6. Badmaeva, E. N. Tserkovnaya politika sovetskogo gosudarstva v Kalmykii v 1921–1922 gg. [Church policy of the Soviet state in Kalmykia in 1921–1922]. Buddiyskaya kultura i mirovaya tsivilizatsiya na poroge III tysyacheletiya [Buddhist culture and world civilization on the threshold of the III millennium]. Saint Petersburg: Saint Petersburg State University; 2000, pp. 203–205.

7. Bakaeva, E. P. Buddizm v Kalmykii. Istoriko-etnograficheskie ocherki [Buddhism in Kalmykia. Historical and Ethnographic Essays]. Elista: Kalmyk Book Publishing House; 1994, 128 p.

8. Bakaeva, E. P. Repressii protiv duhovenstva: o zakrytii vysshey konfessionalnoy shkoly Cheerya v Kalmykii [Repressions against the Clergy: On the Closure of the Cheerya Higher Confessional School in Kalmykia]. Vestnik Buryatskogo nauchnogo tsentra SO RAN [Bulletin of the Buryat Scientific Center of the Siberian Branch of the Russian Academy of Sciences]. 2013, no. 4, pp. 7–14.

9. Baskhaev, A. N. Buddiyskaya tserkov v Kalmykii: 1900−1943 gg. [Buddhist Church in Kalmykia: 1900–1943]. Elista: Dzhangar; 2007, 240 p.

10. Borisenko, I. V. Khramy Kalmykii [Temples of Kalmykia]. Elista: Dzhangar; 1994, 20 p.

11. Vasileva, O. Yu. Russkaya Pravoslavnaya Tserkov v politike Sovetskogo gosudarstva v 1943–1948 gg. [The Russian Orthodox Church in the Policy of the Soviet State in 1943–1948]. Moscow: Institute of Russian History; 2001, 212 p.

12. State Archives of the Russian Federation. Fund A 501, inventory 1, case 1620.

13. State Archives of the Russian Federation. Fund A 501, inventory 1, case 2170.

14. State Archives of the Russian Federation. Fund A 501, inventory 1, case 2656.

15. Gorbatov, A. V. Buddisty i Sovetskoe gosudarstvo v 1946–1960-e gg. [Buddhists and the Soviet State in the 1946–1960]. Rossiyskaya istoriya [Russian History]. 2018, no. 5, pp. 77–88, doi: 10.31857/S086956870001572-7.

16. State Archives of the Saratov Region. Fund R-3650, inventory 1, case 4.

17. Dordzhieva, G. Sh. Buddiyskaya tserkov Kalmykii v kontse XIX – pervoy polovine XX v. [The Buddhist Church of Kalmykia in the Late 19th – First Half of the 20th Century]. Moscow: Institute of Russian History of the Russian Academy of Sciences; 2001, 181 p.

18. Dordzhieva, G. Sh. Repressirovannoe buddiyskoe duhovenstvo v Kalmykii [The Repressed Buddhist Clergy in Kalmykia]. Elista: Kalmyk State University; 2014, 191 p.

19. Kozlov, F. N. Zakrytie tserkvey kak element gosudarstvennoy antireligioznoy politiki v konce 1920-kh – nachale 1930-kh godov (po materialam natsionalnykh respublik Srednego Povolzhya) [Closing of churches as an element of state anti-religious policy in the late 1920s – early 1930s (based on materials from the national republics of the Middle Volga region)]. Vestnik Chuvashskogo universiteta [Bulletin of the Chuvash University]. 2014, no. 1, pp. 26–34.

20. Kochetov, A. N. Lamaizm [Lamaism]. Moscow: Nauka; 1973, 200 p.

21. Kuznetsova, A. S. Panchen-ertni Choeki Gyaltsan (Panchen-lama X) i politika KPK v Tibete [Panchen-ertni Choeki Gyaltsan (Panchen Lama 10th) and the policy of the CPC in Tibet]. Prepodavatel. XXI vek [Lecturer. 21th century]. 2015, no. 3–2, pp. 359–366.

22.  Lamaizm v Kalmykii [Lamaism in Kalmykia]. Elista: Kalmyk Scientific Research Institute of Language, Literature and History; 1977, 112 p.

23. Lidzhieva, I. V. Puti khozyaystvennogo razvitiya Kalmytskoy stepi v otsenkakh stolichnykh chinovnikov (poslednyaya tret XIX – nachalo XX vekov) [Paths of Economic Development of the Kalmyk Steppe in the Assessments of Moscow Officials (Last Third of the 19th – early 20th Centuries)]. Novyy istoricheskiy vestnik [New Historical Herald]. 2022, no. 4 (74), pp. 48–62, doi: 10.54770/20729286_2022_4_48.

24. Maksimov, K. N. Tragediya naroda. Repressii v Kalmykii. 1918–1940-e gody. [Tragedy of the People. Repressions in Kalmykia. 1918–1940s]. Moscow: Nauka; 2004, 311 p.

25. Maksimov, K. N. Antireligioznaya politika sovetskoy vlasti v Kalmykii (1918–1928 gg.) [Anti-religious Policy of the Soviet Power in Kalmykia (1918–1928)]. Problemy istorii massovykh politicheskikh repressiy v SSSR. 1953–2013: 60 let bez Stalina. Osmyslenie proshlogo sovetskogo gosudarstva [Problems of the History of Mass Political Repressions in the USSR. 1953–2013: 60 Years Without Stalin. Understanding the Past of the Soviet State]. Krasnodar: Ekoinvest; 2013, part 2, pp. 167–178.

26. Mitirov, A. G. K istorii Arshi Bakshin khurula [On the history of Arshi Bakshin khurul]. Buddiyskaya traditsiya v Kalmykii v XX veke: pamyati O. M. Dordzhieva (Tugmyud gavdzhi). 1887–1980 [Buddhist tradition in Kalmykia in the 20th century: in memory of O. M. Dordzhiev (Tugmyud gavdzhi). 1887–1980.]. Elista: Kalmyk Scientific Research Institute of History, Philology and Economics; 2008, pp. 146–149.

27. Muzraeva, D. N. Buddiyskiye pismennyye istochniki na tibetskom i oyratskom yazykakh v kollektsiyakh Kalmykii [Buddhist written sources in the Tibetan and Oirat languages in the collections of Kalmykia]. Elista: Dzhangar; 2012, 224 p.

28. Muchaeva, I. I. Formirovanie kalmytskoy kollektsii muzeya Severnogo Kavkaza [Formation of the Kalmyk collection of the North Caucasus Museum]. Kunstkamera [Kunstkamera]. 2024, no. 2, pp. 168–177, doi: 10.31250/2618-8619-2024-2(24)-168-177.

29. Muchaeva, I. I. Buddiyskie kollektsii v muzeynom prostranstve Rossii: prichiny i usloviya formirovaniya [Buddhist Collections in the Museum Space of Russia: Causes and Conditions of Formation]. Nomadic Civilization: Historical Research [Nomadic Civilization: Historical Research]. 2025, vol. 5, no. 1, pp. 62–73, doi: 10.53315/2782-3377-2025-5-1-62-73.

30. Odintsov, M. I. Veroispovednaya politika Sovetskogo gosudarstva v 1939–1958 gg. [Religious Policy of the Soviet State in 1939–1958]. Vlast i Tserkov v SSSR i stranakh Vostochnoy Evropy. 1939–1958 [Power and the Church in the USSR and Eastern European Countries. 1939–1958]. Moscow: Institute of Slavic Studies; 2003, pp. 7–68.

31. Orlova, K. V. Tsanid Chere v Kalmykii [Tsanid Chöre in Kalmykia]. Buryat-mongoly nakanune III tysyacheletiya: opyt kochevoy tsivilizatsii. Rossiya – Vostok – Zapad v sudbe naroda [Buryat Mongols on the Eve of the Third Millennium: The Experience of Nomadic Civilization. Russia – East – West in the Fate of a People]. Ulan-Ude: Buryat Scientific Center of the Siberian Branch of the Russian Academy of Sciences; 1997, pp. 111–112.

32. Reabilitatsiya: kak eto bylo. Dokumenty Prezidiuma CK KPSS i drugie materialy [Rehabilitation: How It Was. Documents of the Presidium of the Central Committee of the CPSU and Other Materials]. Moscow: Demokratiya; 2003, vol. 2, 960 p.

33. Stavropolskiy gosudarstvennyy istoriko-kulturnyy i prirodno-landshaftnyy muzey-zapovednik im. G. N. Prozriteleva i G. K Prave [Stavropol State Historical, Cultural and Natural Landscape Museum-Reserve named after G. N. Prozritelev and G. K. Prave]. KP 2974/1 (main collection).

34. Ubushieva, S. I. Ateisticheskaya propaganda v Kalmykii [Atheistic Propaganda in Kalmykia]. Elista: Kalmyk Book Publishing House; 1986, 71 p.

35. Ulanov, M. S. Kalmycko-mongolskie religioznye svyazi: istoricheskiy opyt i sovremennost [Kalmyk-Mongolian religious ties: historical experience and modernity]. Vostokovednye issledovaniya v Kalmykii [Oriental studies in Kalmykia]. Elista: Kalmyk State University; 2007,
iss. 3, pp. 43–49.

36. Tselovalnikova, I. I., Ilyazova, R. V. Realizatsiya normativno-pravovykh aktov v sfere antireligioznoy politiki v SSSR v konce 1920-kh – 1930-e gg. (na primere Ulyanovskoy gubernii) [Implementation of normative legal acts in the sphere of anti-religious policy in the USSR in the late 1920s – 1930s (on the example of the Ulyanovsk province)]. Vlast [Power]. 2015, no. 1, pp. 109–112.

37. Terentyev, A. Tibetan Buddhism in Russia. The Tibet Journal. 1996, vol. 21, no. 3, pp. 60–70.

Popular articles