kaspyTHE CASPIAN REGION: politics, economics, culture1818-510XАстраханский государственный университет им. В. Н. Татищева225910.54398/1818510Х_2023_2_8194(470)“19/…”Sauna relations: The ethnoecological component of nomads ethnic and ethnosocial stratificationSauna relations: The ethnoecological component of nomads ethnic and ethnosocial stratificationhttps://orcid.org/0000-0002-2153-6459SadovoyAlexander N.SadovoyAlexander N.sadovoy.a.n@gmail.comSubtropical Scientific Centre of the RASSubtropical Scientific Centre of the RAS17072023281901003202327032023https://kaspy.asu-edu.ru/en/archive/2023/issue/2/article/2259https://kaspy.asu-edu.ru/storage/kaspy/archive/2(75)/81-90.pdf

The change in scientific paradigms and methodological approaches in the study of "nomad" societies increase the relevance of the study of modern processes of ethnic stratification among ethnic groups that have retained traditional economic specialization. The purpose of the study was to identify the mechanism (complex of cause-and-effect relationships) of ethnic stratification among the ethnic groups of mountain ecosystems that retain their traditional economic specialization in the field of cattle breeding. Statistical data of the end of the 19th century, historiographic sources on the subject and author field materials were used. The methodological basis was systemic, process, selective approaches. The research algorithm was determined by a set of developed methods. On the basis of the analysis carried out, an assessment was made of autochthonous ethnic groups traditional system of subsistence as a multi-plane, hierarchically subordinate and balanced ethno-ecosystem, within the boundaries of which the processes of population reproduction were determined by the system reproducible natural resources redistribution. It was revealed that the traditional society social stratification had an undeniable impact on both the land use system and the sources of life support in all social strata. It is noted that in the society of "nomads" production-territorial ties dominated, while maintaining the historical memory of its class structure, as a guarantor of maintaining a relatively high welfare. The mobile livestock species concentration of limited number of families ownership (with a sauna system of relations) determined the idea of the priority right of this social stratum to regulate grazing in separate valley complexes

The change in scientific paradigms and methodological approaches in the study of "nomad" societies increase the relevance of the study of modern processes of ethnic stratification among ethnic groups that have retained traditional economic specialization. The purpose of the study was to identify the mechanism (complex of cause-and-effect relationships) of ethnic stratification among the ethnic groups of mountain ecosystems that retain their traditional economic specialization in the field of cattle breeding. Statistical data of the end of the 19th century, historiographic sources on the subject and author field materials were used. The methodological basis was systemic, process, selective approaches. The research algorithm was determined by a set of developed methods. On the basis of the analysis carried out, an assessment was made of autochthonous ethnic groups traditional system of subsistence as a multi-plane, hierarchically subordinate and balanced ethno-ecosystem, within the boundaries of which the processes of population reproduction were determined by the system reproducible natural resources redistribution. It was revealed that the traditional society social stratification had an undeniable impact on both the land use system and the sources of life support in all social strata. It is noted that in the society of "nomads" production-territorial ties dominated, while maintaining the historical memory of its class structure, as a guarantor of maintaining a relatively high welfare. The mobile livestock species concentration of limited number of families ownership (with a sauna system of relations) determined the idea of the priority right of this social stratum to regulate grazing in separate valley complexes

methodologysystemic approachintra- and inter-ethnic communicationscomparative analysisethnic and ethnosocial stratificationsauna relationsGorny Altaiautochthonous population life support systemsnature managementmethodologysystemic approachintra- and inter-ethnic communicationscomparative analysisethnic and ethnosocial stratificationsauna relationsGorny Altaiautochthonous population life support systemsnature managementThe study was carried out within the framework of the State Assignment of Federal Research Centre the Subtropical Scientific Centre of the Russian Academy of Sciences “Monitoring the Ethno-Social Situation in the Constituent Entities of the Russian Federation: Methodology and Methods of Information Support for National Policy” (registration number 122032300400-5 FGRW-2021-0014).The study was carried out within the framework of the State Assignment of Federal Research Centre the Subtropical Scientific Centre of the Russian Academy of Sciences “Monitoring the Ethno-Social Situation in the Constituent Entities of the Russian Federation: Methodology and Methods of Information Support for National Policy” (registration number 122032300400-5 FGRW-2021-0014).Bakhmatov, B. F. O sushchnosti patriarhalno-feodalnykh otnosheniy u kochevykh narodov Kazakhstana [On the essence of patriarchal-feudal relations among the nomadic peoples of Kazakhstan]. Materialy nauchnoy sessii po istorii narodov Sredney Azii i Kazakhstana [Materials of the scientific session on the history of the peoples of Central Asia and Kazakhstan]. – Tashkent, 1955 [Reprint. Archive of the Laboratory of Ethno-Social Research of the FRC SNC RAS (Sochi)]. Bakhmatov, B. F. O sushchnosti patriarhalno-feodalnykh otnosheniy u kochevykh narodov Kazakhstana [On the essence of patriarchal-feudal relations among the nomadic peoples of Kazakhstan]. Materialy nauchnoy sessii po istorii narodov Sredney Azii i Kazakhstana [Materials of the scientific session on the history of the peoples of Central Asia and Kazakhstan]. – Tashkent, 1955 [Reprint. Archive of the Laboratory of Ethno-Social Research of the FRC SNC RAS (Sochi)]. Vladimirov, V. N. Khozyaystvo yuzhnykh altaytsev v kontse XVIII – pervoy polovine XIX vv. [The economy of the southern Altaians at the end of the 18th – the first half of the 19th centuries]. Arkheologiya i etnografiya Yuzhnoy Sibiri [Archeology and ethnography of Southern Siberia]. Barnaul: Altay State University; 1990, pp. 150–161.Vladimirov, V. N. Khozyaystvo yuzhnykh altaytsev v kontse XVIII – pervoy polovine XIX vv. [The economy of the southern Altaians at the end of the 18th – the first half of the 19th centuries]. Arkheologiya i etnografiya Yuzhnoy Sibiri [Archeology and ethnography of Southern Siberia]. Barnaul: Altay State University; 1990, pp. 150–161.Ekeev, N. V. Sotsialno-ekonomicheskoe razvitie derevni Gornogo Altaya v 1920-kh gg. [Socio-economic development of the village of Gorny Altai in the 1920s]. Gorno-Altaysk: Altay book publishing house; 1988, 208 p.Ekeev, N. V. Sotsialno-ekonomicheskoe razvitie derevni Gornogo Altaya v 1920-kh gg. [Socio-economic development of the village of Gorny Altai in the 1920s]. Gorno-Altaysk: Altay book publishing house; 1988, 208 p.Markov, G. E. Nekotorye problemy obshchestvennoy organizatsii kochevnikov Azii [Some problems of the social organization of Asian nomads]. Sovetskaya etnografiya [Soviet ethnography]. 1970, no. 6, pp. 74–89.Markov, G. E. Nekotorye problemy obshchestvennoy organizatsii kochevnikov Azii [Some problems of the social organization of Asian nomads]. Sovetskaya etnografiya [Soviet ethnography]. 1970, no. 6, pp. 74–89.Markov, G. E. Problemy razvitiya obshchestvennoy struktury kochevnikov Azii [Problems of development of the social structure of nomads in Asia]. Moscow: Nauka, Glavn. Red. Vost. Literatury; 1973, 320 p.Markov, G. E. Problemy razvitiya obshchestvennoy struktury kochevnikov Azii [Problems of development of the social structure of nomads in Asia]. Moscow: Nauka, Glavn. Red. Vost. Literatury; 1973, 320 p.Markov, G. E. Skotovodcheskoe khozyaystvo i kochevnichestvo, definitsii i terminologiya [Pastoral economy and nomadism, definitions and terminology]. Sovetskaya etnografiya [Soviet ethnography]. 1981, no. 4, pp. 83–95.Markov, G. E. Skotovodcheskoe khozyaystvo i kochevnichestvo, definitsii i terminologiya [Pastoral economy and nomadism, definitions and terminology]. Sovetskaya etnografiya [Soviet ethnography]. 1981, no. 4, pp. 83–95.Mordkovich, V. G. Stepnye ekosistemy [Steppe ecosystems]. Novosibirsk: Nauka; 1982, 192 p.Mordkovich, V. G. Stepnye ekosistemy [Steppe ecosystems]. Novosibirsk: Nauka; 1982, 192 p.Ogureeva, G. N. Botanicheskaya geografiya Altaya [Botanical geography of Altai]. Moscow: Nauka; 1980, 190 p.Ogureeva, G. N. Botanicheskaya geografiya Altaya [Botanical geography of Altai]. Moscow: Nauka; 1980, 190 p.Pershic, A. I. K voprosu o saunnykh otnosheniyakh [On the issue of sauna relations]. Osnovnye problemy afrikanistiki: etnografiya, istoriya, filologiya [Main problems of African studies: ethnography, history, philology]. Moscow: Nauka; 1973, pp. 104–110.Pershic, A. I. K voprosu o saunnykh otnosheniyakh [On the issue of sauna relations]. Osnovnye problemy afrikanistiki: etnografiya, istoriya, filologiya [Main problems of African studies: ethnography, history, philology]. Moscow: Nauka; 1973, pp. 104–110. Pogorelskiy, P., Batrakov, V. Ekonomika kochevogo aula Kirgizstana [Economy of the nomadic village of Kyrgyzstan]. Moscow: SovNA RKom KASSR; 1930, 291 p. Pogorelskiy, P., Batrakov, V. Ekonomika kochevogo aula Kirgizstana [Economy of the nomadic village of Kyrgyzstan]. Moscow: SovNA RKom KASSR; 1930, 291 p. Poddubikov, V. V, Sadovoy, A. N., Belozerova, M. V. Ekspertiza i monitoring traditsionnykh form prirodopolzovaniya korennykh malochislennykh etnosov: metody prikladnoy etnologii [Expertise and monitoring of traditional forms of nature management of indigenous small-numbered ethnic groups: methods of applied ethnology]. Kemerovo: Praktika; 2014, 358 p. Poddubikov, V. V, Sadovoy, A. N., Belozerova, M. V. Ekspertiza i monitoring traditsionnykh form prirodopolzovaniya korennykh malochislennykh etnosov: metody prikladnoy etnologii [Expertise and monitoring of traditional forms of nature management of indigenous small-numbered ethnic groups: methods of applied ethnology]. Kemerovo: Praktika; 2014, 358 p. Potapov, L. P. O sushchnosti patriarhalno-feodalnykh otnosheniy u kochevykh narodov Sredney Azii i Kazahstana [On the essence of patriarchal-feudal relations among the nomadic peoples of Central Asia and Kazakhstan]. Materialy nauchnoy sessii, posvyashchennoy istorii Sredney Azii i Kazakhstana v dooktyabrskiy period [Materials of a scientific session on the history of Central Asia and Kazakhstan in the pre-October period]. Tashkent: AS USSR; 1955, pp. 17–42. Potapov, L. P. O sushchnosti patriarhalno-feodalnykh otnosheniy u kochevykh narodov Sredney Azii i Kazahstana [On the essence of patriarchal-feudal relations among the nomadic peoples of Central Asia and Kazakhstan]. Materialy nauchnoy sessii, posvyashchennoy istorii Sredney Azii i Kazakhstana v dooktyabrskiy period [Materials of a scientific session on the history of Central Asia and Kazakhstan in the pre-October period]. Tashkent: AS USSR; 1955, pp. 17–42.Potapov, L. P. Ocherki istorii Oyotii [Essays on the history of Oirotia]. Novosibirsk: ZSKPT; 1933, 204 p.Potapov, L. P. Ocherki istorii Oyotii [Essays on the history of Oirotia]. Novosibirsk: ZSKPT; 1933, 204 p.Potapov, L. P. Razlozhenie rodovogo stroya u plemen Severnogo Altaya [Decomposition of the tribal system among the tribes of the Northern Altai]. Moscow – Leningrad: OGIZ; 1935, 121 p.Potapov, L. P. Razlozhenie rodovogo stroya u plemen Severnogo Altaya [Decomposition of the tribal system among the tribes of the Northern Altai]. Moscow – Leningrad: OGIZ; 1935, 121 p. Potapov, L. P. Ocherki po istorii altaytsev [Essays on the history of the Altaians]. Moscow – Leningrad: AS USSR; 1953, 444 p. Potapov, L. P. Ocherki po istorii altaytsev [Essays on the history of the Altaians]. Moscow – Leningrad: AS USSR; 1953, 444 p.Sadovoy, A. N. Territorialnaya obshchina Gornogo Altaya i Shorii (konets XIX – nach. XX vv.) [Territorial community of Gorny Altai and Shoria (late 19th – early 20th centuries)]. Kemerovo: Kuzbassvuzizdat; 1992, 198 p.Sadovoy, A. N. Territorialnaya obshchina Gornogo Altaya i Shorii (konets XIX – nach. XX vv.) [Territorial community of Gorny Altai and Shoria (late 19th – early 20th centuries)]. Kemerovo: Kuzbassvuzizdat; 1992, 198 p. Sadovoy, A. N. Narody Yuzhnoy Sibiri v XIX–XX vv. Etnosotsialnye aspekty paternalizma [Peoples of Southern Siberia in the 19th–20th centuries. Ethno-social aspects of paternalism]. Sankt Petersburg: 2000, 587 p. Sadovoy, A. N. Narody Yuzhnoy Sibiri v XIX–XX vv. Etnosotsialnye aspekty paternalizma [Peoples of Southern Siberia in the 19th–20th centuries. Ethno-social aspects of paternalism]. Sankt Petersburg: 2000, 587 p.Semenov, Yu. I. Kochevnichestvo i nekotorye obshchie problemy teorii khozyaystva i obshchestva [Nomadism and some general problems of the theory of economy and society]. Sovetskaya etnografiya [Soviet ethnography]. 1982, no. 2, pp. 48–59.Semenov, Yu. I. Kochevnichestvo i nekotorye obshchie problemy teorii khozyaystva i obshchestva [Nomadism and some general problems of the theory of economy and society]. Sovetskaya etnografiya [Soviet ethnography]. 1982, no. 2, pp. 48–59.Stalin, I. V. Ob ocherednykh zadachakh partii v natsionalnom voprose: Tezisy k X sezdu RKP(b), (8–16 marta 1921 g.), utverzhdennye TsK partii. Razdel II. Ocherednye zadachi RKP (b). Sochineniya [On the immediate tasks of the party in the national question: Theses for the Tenth Congress of the RCP (b), (March 8–16, 1921), approved by the Central Committee of the party. Section II. Immediate tasks of the RCP (b). Works]. Vol. 5, pp. 24–25. Available at: https://c21ch.newcastle.edu.au/stalin/t5/t5_03.htm#par1 (accessed: 01.03.2023).Stalin, I. V. Ob ocherednykh zadachakh partii v natsionalnom voprose: Tezisy k X sezdu RKP(b), (8–16 marta 1921 g.), utverzhdennye TsK partii. Razdel II. Ocherednye zadachi RKP (b). Sochineniya [On the immediate tasks of the party in the national question: Theses for the Tenth Congress of the RCP (b), (March 8–16, 1921), approved by the Central Committee of the party. Section II. Immediate tasks of the RCP (b). Works]. Vol. 5, pp. 24–25. Available at: https://c21ch.newcastle.edu.au/stalin/t5/t5_03.htm#par1 (accessed: 01.03.2023).Tokarev, S. A. Dokapitalisticheskie perezhitki v Oyrotii [Pre-capitalist remnants in Oirotia]. Leningrad: Sotsialno-ekonomicheskoe izdatelstvo, Leningradskoe otdelenie; 1936, 156 p.Tokarev, S. A. Dokapitalisticheskie perezhitki v Oyrotii [Pre-capitalist remnants in Oirotia]. Leningrad: Sotsialno-ekonomicheskoe izdatelstvo, Leningradskoe otdelenie; 1936, 156 p.Tolstov, S. P. Genezis feodalizma v kochevykh skotovodcheskikh obshchestvakh [Genesis of feudalism in nomadic pastoral societies]. Izvestiya Gosudarstvennoy Akademii istorii materialnoy kultury [Proceedings of the State Academy of the History of Material Culture]. 1934, iss. 103, pp. 165–203.Tolstov, S. P. Genezis feodalizma v kochevykh skotovodcheskikh obshchestvakh [Genesis of feudalism in nomadic pastoral societies]. Izvestiya Gosudarstvennoy Akademii istorii materialnoy kultury [Proceedings of the State Academy of the History of Material Culture]. 1934, iss. 103, pp. 165–203.Tolybekov, S. E. Kochevoe obshhestvo kazahov v XVII – nachale XX vv. [Kazakh nomadic society in the 17th – early 20th centuries]. Alma-Ata: Nauka; 1971, 634 p.Tolybekov, S. E. Kochevoe obshhestvo kazahov v XVII – nachale XX vv. [Kazakh nomadic society in the 17th – early 20th centuries]. Alma-Ata: Nauka; 1971, 634 p.